There's a word people use for celebrating with friends instead of family during the holidays. The word is "backup."
As in: "I can't make it home, so I'm doing Friendsgiving as a backup." As in: "It's not the real thing, but it's something." As in: the people you chose are the consolation prize for the people you didn't.
Here's what I want to push back on: chosen family is not a backup plan. It is a plan. And for a lot of people in their 20s, it is the most real, honest, and nourishing version of the holidays they have access to.
This post is for the people who are going to spend the holidays with friends and feel, somewhere underneath the fun, like they're supposed to apologize for it.
Why we frame chosen family as second-best
The cultural script of the holidays is built around a very specific picture: a table full of people who share your blood and your last name, a house that is familiar, a tradition that goes back further than you can remember. That picture has a lot of weight behind it. TV, movies, your relatives' Instagram, the question "are you going home for the holidays" said with the full assumption that "home" means wherever your parents are.
When your actual situation doesn't match the picture, there's a gap. And the gap tends to feel like a failure, even when it isn't one.
Some people's families of origin are genuinely wonderful and the holidays with them are genuinely good. If that's you, great. This post is not for you.
But a lot of people's families are complicated, or distant, or estranged, or simply not accessible given the financial and logistical realities of being in their 20s. And for those people, spending the holidays with friends isn't a failure to get the real thing. It's a choice, made from real circumstances, to be with people who actually make you feel good.
The internalized hierarchy that says that's lesser is worth examining.
What chosen family actually means
Chosen family isn't a modern euphemism for "people I hang out with." It's a recognized psychological and sociological concept with real research behind it, and it refers to relationships that provide the same functional support as family of origin: belonging, consistency, care, and the particular comfort of people who know you over time.
These relationships are especially significant for people who are LGBTQ+, estranged from family, grew up in difficult home environments, or have simply built their primary community away from where they're from. But honestly, they're significant for a lot of people in their 20s who are living in cities away from home and building a life that their family of origin is only partially a part of.
The research on belonging and mental health is consistent: what matters is not the type of relationship but the quality of it. A holiday with friends who make you feel seen, safe, and genuinely wanted is better for you than a holiday with family where you feel like a guest in a dynamic you can't change.
On the grief that sometimes comes with it anyway
Here is the complicated part: you can know all of the above and still feel sad.
Grief about family is not always grief about a specific person or thing you lost. Sometimes it's grief about the version of things you wanted and don't have. The table from the picture. The feeling of belonging to a lineage. The specific comfort of being taken care of by someone who knew you before you were old enough to take care of yourself.
You can hold that grief and still have a genuinely good holiday with the people you chose. You can carry both of those things. The grief doesn't mean Friendsgiving is a lesser option. It means you're human and you wanted something specific and your life looks a little different than that.
If that grief is big or old or persistent, the holidays are a reasonable time to look at it, maybe with a therapist.
How to actually let yourself enjoy it
Show up without the qualifier. The mental footnote that says "this is good, for what it is" is the thing that keeps you from just experiencing it as good. Notice when you're running that thought and see if you can set it down.
Build a ritual. Part of what gives family holidays their weight is that they repeat, and over time the repetition becomes meaning. If you've been doing Friendsgiving for a few years, you already have rituals, even if you don't call them that. If this is the first year, the ritual starts now.
Tell people what this means to you. You don't have to give a speech. But the people around your table probably also needed someone to build a table with. Saying that out loud, even once, is worth something.
Frequently asked questions
Is it normal to feel lonely during the holidays even when I'm surrounded by people?
Very much so. Loneliness is not about the number of people present. It's about the quality of connection and the gap between the belonging you have and the belonging you wanted. If you're with friends but still feel the absence of something, that's not ingratitude. That's just an honest account of what you're experiencing.
My family is difficult to be around but I still feel guilty not going home. How do I handle that?
Guilt about choosing your own wellbeing is very common, especially around family. It helps to separate the question of what you feel from the question of what you should do. You can feel guilty and still make the right choice for yourself. Those two things can coexist. If the guilt is chronic and heavy, that's worth exploring in therapy.
How do I stop comparing my holidays to what I see on social media?
By remembering that what you see on social media is the edited version. People post what they want to have on record, not necessarily what's real. The families that look perfect in the photos have dynamics that don't appear in them. Comparison to a curated highlight reel is not a fair comparison. Limiting your use of it during high-comparison periods is a reasonable and effective move.
I want to celebrate with friends but feel like I'm abandoning my family. How do I talk to them about it?
Early, directly, and without over-explaining. "I'm spending the holiday with friends this year" is a statement, not a negotiation. If your family presses, "this is what I need this year" is usually sufficient. You are allowed to make decisions about your own time without consensus from the people affected by them.
What do I do if I'm going to be completely alone for the holidays?
First, check whether "completely alone" is actually true or whether it's a fear. Reach out to people earlier than feels comfortable. Someone else is probably also dreading an empty holiday and waiting for someone to suggest something. If you are genuinely going to be alone, give yourself permission to make it into something you actually want rather than a day you're just getting through. And if the aloneness is heavier than a day can hold, that's worth talking to someone about.
Is it okay to have mixed feelings about spending the holidays with chosen family?
Yes. Mixed feelings are just feelings that contain more than one thing, which is accurate to most real experiences. You can be glad to be with the people you chose and also sad about the version of things you wanted. Both of those are real.
How can therapy help with family estrangement or grief during the holidays?
Therapy can help you understand what you're grieving, separate that grief from guilt or self-blame, and build a way of moving through the holidays that isn't organized around absence. It can also just be a space where you're allowed to say the complicated thing without having to manage how someone else receives it.
My friends and I keep saying we'll do Friendsgiving but it never happens. How do I actually make it happen?
Pick a date and name it. Then make one specific ask to two or three specific people. Group chats where everyone agrees something sounds fun and nobody does anything about it are a planning failure, not an interest failure. Somebody has to be the one who picks a date and calls it a thing. It might as well be you.
Meet a specialist
If this season is bringing up bigger questions about family, belonging, or grief, we want you to meet one of our therapists.
We focus on working with young adults navigating identity, relationships, and the particular complexity of family dynamics in your 20s. They approach this work with warmth and directness, and are especially good with clients who are still figuring out what they want their family of origin to mean to their adult life.
Availability and cost available on a range to meet the needs of all people. Head to theboundarynyc.com to learn more or book a free phone consultation.
If you or someone you know is in a crisis, call 911 or contact the Suicide and Crisis Lifeline at 988.



